Kenna Morton's Journal, 04 Feb 19

Here is a quick and dirty on how obesity is measured.
Many times I have read people’s comments on how stupid and out of touch the medical community is to still be using the antiquated BMI system. There are several methods for measuring obesity but they are costly,not portable and not easily accessible for many people. They also are probably not covered by insurance.. That being said, the WHO (World Health Organization) and the NIH (National Institute. Of Health) use the BMI to distinguish different categories of weight status in adults. It is the ratio of height to weight and is the most basic, inexpensive and most common measurement used to assess and screen an individual for obesity. The medical community is well aware of the limitations of the BMI— it does not distinguish between someone who has a lot of body fat and somone with a llot of body muscle. it also does not take into account variances in age, gender race or ethnicity. Despite these limitations, the BMI has been widely adopted as the most effective, easy to administer clinical tool for screening individuals for classification of degree of obesity. Numerous studies have correlated BMI scores with increase risk of premature death and chronic illness. The waist to hip ratio method is the second most commonly used. It can determine whether you are a pear or an apple shape. Meaning, do you have more central or abdominal fat. Abdominal obesity has been shown to directly correlate to cardiovascular disease, diabetes, metabolic disorders and cancer.
The skin fold method requires a number of mathematical formulas, results are often inaccurate and irreproducible. Measurements for someone with a BMI of greater than 35 are hard to obtain due to caliper limitations and are fairly inaccurate.

View Diet Calendar, 04 February 2019:
1322 kcal Fat: 64.96g | Prot: 43.41g | Carbs: 146.38g.   Breakfast: Sara beth spreadable fruit Mixed berry jam, French's No Salt, Egg, Welch's Concord Grape Fruit Juice Cocktail, Maxwell House International Cafe Orange, Oroweat Organic Thin Sliced 22 Grains & Seeds, Aqua de Jamaica (hibiscus ice tea). Lunch: Chobani Nonfat Plain Greek Yogurt, Driscoll's Blueberries, Chobani Nonfat Vanilla Blended Greek Yogurt (Container), Tru-Nut Powdered Peanut Butter, Ranch Granola, 2% Fat Milk, Nature's Path Heritage Flakes Multigrain Cereal. Dinner: Hillshire Farm Beef Polska Kielbasa, Aqua de Jamaica (hibiscus ice tea), Pompeian Balsamic and Pomegranate Balsamic Vinegar, Tomatoes, LouAna Pure Canola Oil, ShopRite Cauliflower Florets, Brussels Sprouts, Cooked Broccoli (Fat Not Added in Cooking), Russet Potatoes (Flesh and Skin, Baked). Snacks/Other: Chocolate Zucchini Cake— Sally’s Baking Addiction.com. more...
1857 kcal Exercise: Walking (slow) - 2/mph - 1 hour, Grocery Shopping - 1 hour, Studying - 2 hours, Swimming (slow) - 2 hours, Resting - 10 hours, Sleeping - 8 hours. more...

3 Supporters    Support   

Comments 
Waist to hip or waist to height ratio? 
04 Feb 19 by member: liv001
Waist to hips. 
04 Feb 19 by member: Kenna Morton
BMI is height to weight. 
04 Feb 19 by member: Kenna Morton
Huh so why is waist to height not considered 
04 Feb 19 by member: liv001
Because you are looking at body shape — central obesity as apposed to abdominal obesity. Your height has no direct bearing on your waist measurement. 
04 Feb 19 by member: Kenna Morton
I read about the waist to hip measurement. It was interesting.  
04 Feb 19 by member: liv001
You can check articles on waist to height measurement on line. Some people argue it is a better identifyer than BMI.  
04 Feb 19 by member: liv001
In the post I just wrote I talked about why it is not used consistently. For one it is not reliably accurate if you have a BMI greater than 35 
04 Feb 19 by member: Kenna Morton
Yeah thanks a lot. Your post was very helpful. I have to think about body shape as I am a somewhat round person and so bad markers for the common illnesses related to being overweight. Have not developed them but a good incentive to work on getting weight down 
05 Feb 19 by member: liv001

     
 

Submit a Comment


You must sign in to submit a comment. Click here to sign in.
 


Kenna Morton's Weight History


Get the app
    
© 2024 FatSecret. All rights reserved.