-Diablo's Journal, 12 Aug 19

Sometimes I wonder if people hearing the truth about certain dieting techniques is a good or bad thing. I was talking to a friend(childhood friend who asks my opinion and for advice on losing fat) at the gym that I hadn't seen in a while. He spoke of how he has lost 28 pounds using intermittent fasting. He didn't outright say it but I'm positive he believed it caused more fat loss than a regular deficit does. When I told him why it worked, he seemed down about it. He knows how much I know about fat loss so he seemed to take my word for it. He was gung-ho about the loss and this news may have lessened his hype about it. He also mentioned how his nephew(who was there with him) lost a lot of weight on keto. His nephew was in football during high school with some bulk to him but now looked thin with no discernible muscle mass. I really don't think keto is best for someone wanting to shape their body and I told him so.

Idk, just a thought. Did I negatively affect his chances of long term success or enhance them? I know that I wish I had the knowledge I now possess when I started so that I could skip all the headaches of trying every diet.

Maybe in order to stick to these tools, people need to believe they are special. Maybe this is why some people don't like my posts. They are so invested in certain dieting "tools" that they take anything that makes them seem ordinary or not special like a personal attack.

What do you all think? Is the placebo of truly believing what they are doing is special a good thing or is knowing the truth better in the long run? If he and his nephew are never going to take the time to count calories is this placebo needed for them to stick to their plan? My personal opinion is that most people would do best on a varied diet with more flexibility in when and what they can eat. So I side with knowing the truth. I know some need structure so a flexible dieting plan may never work for them.

I took a full 8 hour OT shift and it's dead so excuse the long post, I don't usually do this.

View Diet Calendar, 12 August 2019:
2725 kcal Fat: 87.60g | Prot: 168.66g | Carbs: 440.81g.   Breakfast: 1% Fat Milk, Post S’Mores Cereal, Kellogg's Special K Protein Original Multi-Grain Touch of Cinnamon, Quest Cookies & Cream Protein Bar, Oranges, Peach, Ole Extreme Wellness High Fiber Low Carb Tortillas. Lunch: Ole Extreme Wellness High Fiber Low Carb Tortillas, Oranges, Quest Cookies & Cream Protein Bar, Ole Extreme Wellness High Fiber Low Carb Tortillas, Carl Buddig Corned Beef, Potato Chips, Quest Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Protein Bar. Dinner: Quest Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Protein Bar, Oranges, Cousin Willie's 94% fat free butter popcorn, Quest White Chocolate Raspberry Protein Bar, Pears, Reese's Outrageous!. Snacks/Other: Smucker's Uncrustables Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly Sandwich (80g). more...
3554 kcal Exercise: Bicycling (leisurely) - <10/mph - 4 hours, Sleeping - 18 hours and 50 minutes, Weight Training (moderate) - 1 hour and 10 minutes. more...

44 Supporters    Support   

21 to 40 of 150
Comments 
When people ask me how I lost a lot of weight, they’re eyes glaze over when I say years of using measuring cups to control portions and keeping the online food diary here to create a caloric deficit. 👀 If people have a different route to getting to that coloric deficit, more power to them. 
12 Aug 19 by member: me,myselfandi
facts are facts plain and simple. 
12 Aug 19 by member: Little Red Fox
Diablo- you asked for opinions and comments. Go back to the paragrapgh in your jpurnal post that starts with "Maybe" . Two men in your gym who are are on a journey to weight loas, a healthy lifestyle no matter their personal food choices should be and lifting weights should be affirmed. They both seem to be following the path of a healthy weight and exercise more. You seem to be the one that that has an issue with them reaching goals but not following your own personal choices and agenda. Not every one is on the same journey as you to look like a body builder. There is more than one truth. 
12 Aug 19 by member: crazycatchick
I don't understand why anyone would respond with criticism to an acquaintance who's losing weight and feeling good about it. Why rain on someone's parade, even if you think you know better? 
12 Aug 19 by member: Miraculum
I think that telling someone to count calories to stay within a certain amount and to exercise is really hard for them to hear. They've tried and failed before. It takes a lot of discipline. If you can give someone a simple rule... Don't eat bread or chips or potatoes but go ahead and eat all the bacon eggs and burgers you want and then they lose (not realizing it's from less calories) it seems like something new. It's easy (until the binge). No one wants to hear that I eat 1800 calories a day and lift for an hour and to be honest... I didn't want to hear it either. I wanted to hear about the pills or green tea or something that would make me not hungry...something magical - I did not want to hear that it is eating less and moving more. That's hard! 
12 Aug 19 by member: davidsprincess
Tbrooksjr...that's right. In all things...! 
12 Aug 19 by member: davidsprincess
dp- your husband rained on the parade of others who have been successful in their personal choices and journey and seem to be successful. Nothing in his post implied they asked him for his opinionr or advice. He used word like he thinks, wonders, and they did not say but he thought.He wants others to affirm his one track mind. More than one way to be healthy other than the Diablo way. 
12 Aug 19 by member: crazycatchick
Miraculum I totally agree with you. For most people dieting is a lot in the mind set. No need put more doubts than we already have. I guess if you’re a know-it-all you just can’t help yourself. 
12 Aug 19 by member: MissAnnieinIndy
Lol crazy cat chick... Unsure why you are calling me out to tell me what my husband did. If telling someone why their WOE is working for them means you are "raining on their parade" then so be it. I would never side with you over my husband. He's passionate about helping others where as I don't give two shits if you all starve yourselves. Furthermore... I hate cats. They are filthy, shit in boxes, and then jump up on your countertop. 
12 Aug 19 by member: davidsprincess
DP, people do no one any favors, and are not speaking the truth, when they characterize "LCHF/keto/carnivore" [take your pick] as "Don't eat bread or chips or potatoes but go ahead and eat all the bacon eggs and burgers you want and then they lose." Before I began exploring this WOE, I did a lot of research in available scientific and clinical information, most of which is not reflected in my FS posts. Overweight folks who want a "quick fix" are not ready for the planning and commitment required to effect a *successful* lifestyle change. 
12 Aug 19 by member: Miraculum
And I tell people just that: Do your due diligence, or you will fail.  
12 Aug 19 by member: Miraculum
DP, I'm not saying that you are telling people what you said, but I've seen lots of examples on social media. 
12 Aug 19 by member: Miraculum
In today’s world of everybody gets a trophy and a juice box I think you may have burst someone’s bubble. Everyone has to find what works for them. I have done intermittent fasting, keto, Atkins, sugar busters, South Beach, diet pills etc. Now I am actually eating food based on my BMR. I have never eaten so much food in my life. I am working out and finally losing weight. 
12 Aug 19 by member: beckyyourman
DP - sad comments. my one cat does not jump on counters and adds filth to my home. It is called unconditional love and I am a fur buster clean up the hair. If you and your husband are not diverse in your oponions about health and weight loss that only speaks to your unacceptance of others opinions and life experience.  
12 Aug 19 by member: crazycatchick
os I do not starve myself. Assumption on your part.  
12 Aug 19 by member: crazycatchick
I can see the train a' coming'. . . .  
12 Aug 19 by member: Terrapin12
This is a philosophical question as everyone has their own true even if facts prove they are wrong 😂 Just joking of course. But I think we don’t need to tell no one if they are wrong or wright if someone didn’t ask for the advice or opinion. When people wants to learn anything- they ask questions, they listen different opinions, they are objective and always ready to change they opinions and believes. Otherwise no one would really hear us 
12 Aug 19 by member: selmaperi
I feel a similar struggle with the utter lack of regard for weight maintenance. I don't frankly care how one loses it, but at this point I honestly don't give any loss much merit until I see someone consciously talking about how they are going to maintain WHILE THEY ARE LOSING. If I had a nickel for every person on the FS site alone who used the age old excuse "I'll worry about maintenance when I get to goal" and then gained every single pound back in the 2 year period I've been on here, I would frankly be richer than Donald Trump. It's honestly what keeps me from writing more about what it's like to maintain. Why bother, people seem to be addicted to the thrill and shame of losing and gaining and losing and gaining weight all over again. Try to even suggest one consider a plan or goal for maintenance while they are losing on whatever woe they are on, or suggest maintenance breaks when struggles during a journey arise, and you want to talk about "fingers in the ears". I do want to be helpful on the one hand, but I'm learning to stay in my own lane and "be the change." Perhaps it bugs me because I was that ignorant at one point and cruising the same roller coaster with my body and it wasn't until I was sick of my own excuses and the same outcome after enough gains and losses that I actively and very consciously took my fingers out of my own ears and woke the fu$k up. And, wanting to wake up and face the truth had to come from within. It wasn't based on what any one person said to me unless I was genuinely ready to hear it. So, I assume it is likely that way with others. And, I also need to accept that some will never wake up and that this is okay, too. So, I just continue to set maintenance goals and if it resonates with someone who is ready to get off the weight loss bandwagon, then great. If it doesn't, perhaps the universe feels they have more to learn from their journey before they can let go and enjoy life beyond the weight loss/weight gain roller coaster. Besides, I recognize that even in maintenance I'm still student to this body and continue learning. You never really stop. But, I can state this - as unsexy and boring as maintenance can be - I am down on my knees humbly grateful to be on this end of the spectrum in so many ways I can't even put into words - even if it meant swallowing a lot of hard pills. 
12 Aug 19 by member: Egull1
Yes. So many diiferent ways to achieve the same goal. My hubby is on FS and many follow and he follows. We have different ways to meet our goals and do not follow in eithers footsteps. Personal attatck on me based on y profile name are laughable. Attack my comments well go at it I have tough skin. Good luck everone on youe personal journey and lifestyle choices! 
12 Aug 19 by member: crazycatchick
I really don’t understand why people wouldn’t put in the effort to record their calories. It may take me 10 minutes per day at the most. If that’s what it takes to drop 10, 20, 50 lbs, I’d have done it long ago. Especially with the options available for recording calories. It’s so easy.  
12 Aug 19 by member: love2educate

     
 

Submit a Comment


You must sign in to submit a comment. Click here to sign in.
 


-Diablo's Weight History


Get the app
    
© 2024 FatSecret. All rights reserved.